Back to News
    Industry Insights

    Cleaning Bids Now Turn on Retention, Training and Packaging Proof

    Published by: QINGDAO JAROLL HYGIENE PRODUCTS CO., LTD.

    Cleaning Bids Now Turn on Retention, Training and Packaging Proof
    Cleaning Bids Now Turn on Retention, Training and Packaging ProofView image

    QINGDAO, China — Cleaning contractors are being asked to prove more and promise less. The evidence is not in the sales deck. It sits in retention figures, injury rulings, packaging obligations and contract length. KB Building Services, a 350-person contractor in Omaha, Nebraska, reports overall employee retention of 91.4% [1]. The same article puts the cost of one frontline departure at roughly $3,500 [1]. Those two numbers belong on the same line of a bid sheet, because together they set what a site really costs to keep clean.

    Retention Is a Delivery Metric Now

    The industry benchmark is not flattering. Estimates put frontline janitorial turnover near 200%, and KB's own record before it rebuilt onboarding followed that pattern: 58.5% of new hires left before their 90-day anniversary [1]. After the program, 80.1% pass that mark, and retention climbs to 97.2% among employees who have been promoted [1]. Promotion there is treated as a retention tool rather than a reward.

    For a buyer, the consequence is arithmetic. A crew that keeps its people works from a stable routine, so consumption of gloves, cloths and towels per site settles into a predictable band. A crew that churns repeats training and reorders in bursts, and the bursts arrive as emergency freight and short shipments. When a facilities provider signs a 10-year agreement on the back of a 17-year relationship, it is underwriting a decade of that routine [5].

    Training in the Wrong Language Is a Safety Cost

    A court fined a cleaning contractor $30,000 without conviction and ordered $5,500 in costs after a night-shift cleaner suffered a crushed right hand in a meat grinder [2]. The company had delivered its training and safe work procedures in English to a workforce that included many Karen and Burmese speakers [2]. The finding was not that training was missing. It was that the delivery did not reach the people who needed it.

    The worker spent four nights in hospital and had two operations [2]. Read that against the procurement file: any instruction that depends on the reader's English is an instruction that may not be followed. A format that cuts the amount of reading at the point of use carries less of that risk.

    The Switch Has a Cost That Never Reaches the Quote

    ISSA's guidance on changing cleaning and disinfection products is direct about where transitions fail: employees keep using the old product, move between the two, or mix them, and different chemistries can react on the surface [3]. Surface compatibility and residue are listed ahead of price, because a cheaper product that cracks plastics or leaves a film is not cheaper [3].

    The lesson covers any consumable change, towels included. Ready-to-use wipes remove the measuring and mixing steps, which is why they alter how a shift is staffed and where supplies are stored [3]. A format change is a training event and should be planned as one.

    Packaging Responsibility Arrives State by State

    Eight states have enacted extended producer responsibility laws that reach the cleaning and facility solutions industry: California, Colorado, Maine, Maryland, Minnesota, Oregon, Vermont and Washington [4]. ISSA's updated summary adds Maryland, Vermont and Washington, and now sets out the penalties for noncompliance in all eight [4].

    For a buyer, packaging is no longer a freight detail. Case counts, film, and whether a product arrives in bulk or individually wrapped change the disposal stream and, in EPR states, who pays for it. The packaging line on a specification is turning into a compliance line.

    What a Towel Specification Should Answer Before the Next Bid

    The pressures above converge on one question a buyer can settle this quarter: is the consumable specified tightly enough that a new crew, a new product and a new packaging rule do not each become a separate negotiation? Jaroll builds single-use nonwoven towels for cleaning and care work, in 40 × 80 cm and a 40–130 g/m² weight band.

    • Consumption per site per shift, so a stability problem shows up as variance rather than surprise.
    • One format per task, so staff are not choosing between two products mid-shift.
    • Units per case and per inner pack, stated in the same document as the EPR jurisdiction.
    • The absorbency and wet-strength band the surface needs, tested on a sample instead of assumed.

    Then send the specification out for samples and run it through a real shift. Jaroll supplies disposable nonwoven towels against agreed sizes, weights and pack counts, and the sample is where a buyer learns whether the numbers on the sheet survive a wet floor.

    Sources

    1. ISSA, 2026-10-22. The People Playbook Behind a 91.4% Employee Retention Rate. https://www.issa.com/articles/the-people-playbook-behind-a-91-4-employee-retention-rate/
    2. INCLEAN, 2026-10-21. Language gap costs cleaning contractor $30,000. https://incleanmag.com.au/language-gap-costs-cleaning-contractor-30000/
    3. ISSA, 2026-10-21. Making the Switch: What to Consider When Choosing Cleaning and Disinfection Products. https://www.issa.com/articles/making-the-switch-what-to-consider-when-choosing-cleaning-and-disinfection-products/
    4. ISSA, 2026-10-19. ISSA Leg. & Reg. Update: Updated EPR Resource Now Available. https://www.issa.com/industry-news/government-affairs/issa-leg-reg-update-l-updated-epr-resource-now-available/
    5. INCLEAN, 2026-10-20. City Facilities Management signs 10-year agreement with Coles Group. https://incleanmag.com.au/city-facilities-managements-10-year-agreement-with-coles-group/